My friend Robert, Bob in Another Life suggested I admit my “closet bands” — artists I secretly love but will receive mass amounts of shit for loving once I reveal my allegiance. Everyone has these … cassettes you keep hidden in an unmarked bag in the closet, albums you keep at your parents’ house but won’t let them throw out, CDs hidden among the masses. I will try to remember as many as I can. Taunt me all you want; I do not fear your condemnation.
Ratt — My heavy metal phase was very brief … it basically took me through junior high, two awkward years in between being hooked on Devo, Gary Numan and Sparks and discovering the Cramps, B-52s, Black Flag and the Dead Kennedys, which launched me into all kinds of wonderful shit. The only thing I took away from the heavy metal phase was a love of Ratt … an appreciation I just can’t shake. Even now I’ll find myself rocking out to tracks from “Invasion of Your Privacy” when nobody’s looking. I even saw them in exchange for a friend going to a punk show with me in high school. I pretended to not like it at the time.
Enya — Fine, it’s me and millions of new age housewives keeping her in business. You know you secretly love her voice; you know it helps you sleep sometimes. Maybe it’s the ancient Druid in me, even though the Celts didn’t actually augment their voices with synthesizers.
Don Henley — As much as I want the Eagles as an entity to explode, I have a soft spot for Don Henley’s solo stuff, especially “The End of the Innocence.” I even went to see him in concert in 1989 at the New York State Fair (with Edie Brickell and the New Bohemians opening, which totally ruled). I was happy when Mojo Nixon, after Henley joined him onstage to sing the song, said he would change “Don Henley Must Die” to “Glenn Fry Must Die.” That should have been the title in the first place — “You Belong to the City” and “Smuggler’s Blues,” you just can’t forgive that shit.
Courtney Love — I know, I know. She’s batshit insane and the total opposite of class and annoys everyone everywhere. She steals songs from Billy Corgan and rode on her dead husband’s coattails. Blah, blah, blah. She’s just misunderstood, OK? Don’t ask me to explain it in a way you will accept as reason … but damn, she drives me crazy. When I hear her sing “Malibu” I want to take her on a road trip and give her a footrub in a hotel room at the end of the day. When I hear her sing Fleetwood Mac’s “Gold Dust Woman” I want to run away with her and make out in a diner. When she pushes people off the stage then jumps into the crowd to beat some ass I want her to rape me. When she tries to write checks her voice can’t cash I want to give her a big hug and some tea and tell her everything’s going to be OK.
Eminem — I like one song. That “Without Me” song. I’m sorry, but it grew on me because they would play it at Mogambo when I was visiting Tokyo right as we all had perfect buzzes going and the whole bar would sort’ve fuse into a collective hysteria. Their speaker system is the only way to hear it. To this day when I hear it I want another shot.
Martika — Yes, I own the “Toy Soldiers” cassingle. I bought it when it came out in 1989. I still listen to the song sometimes. Fuck you all. I love Martika.
That’s all I can think of now. Anybody ready to admit theirs?
sid world headquarters
mer | 10-May-05 at 8:37 am | Permalink
how long has it been since you unearthed a Die Kreutzen (still cant spell it), Voivod (the first cd my dog ever ate, I applauded his efforts) or Fields of the Nephlim LP? Jeeesh! More later after I finish puking my lunch!
Superb, honest confessions, Sid!
Oh wait, it’s about bands you actually liked at one time…
OMG–what about OMD???
sid | 10-May-05 at 9:12 am | Permalink
I actually saw Die Kreutzen open for Sonic Youth in 1988 and was glad I never owned an album (though I do like one song only because you put it on a kick-ass mix tape).
Two years later I saw Voivod in the same place. I had never even heard of them, but one of the opening acts, a little outfit called Soundgarden, gave me reason to attend the show. Voivod was terrible, even attempting a metal cover of Pink Floyd’s “Astronomy Domine,” during which I tripped and fell in the pit … I guess it was a Floydian slip (duck).
I listen to Fields because my whole life is one big dark room.
chriss | 10-May-05 at 10:26 am | Permalink
Here’s my list.
Tom | 10-May-05 at 11:50 pm | Permalink
Ahh, the ole’ Lost Horizon! Sid, do you remember the band that opened for Sonic Youth and Die Kreuzen? The Laughing Hyenas. (shudder) What a horrible noise…
As for my closet bands, the only one’s I can think of offhand are Abba, The Georgia Satellites, and a certain Canadian troubadour named…. Bryan Adams.
Tony | 11-May-05 at 4:52 am | Permalink
Orchestrial Maneuvers In The Dark (aka OMD). Thoughtful electronicia, at least I thought so in 1986. I have every album on CD and many on LP too.
The Hooters. I’m from Philadelphia, and you either loved them or hated them. No other choice seemed possible.
DJ Jazzie Jeff & The Fresh Prince. Another Philadelphia homeie that’s normally fun and often intelligent too.
Oh the shame of it all.
shane. | 11-May-05 at 2:06 pm | Permalink
I’ve been thinking about this and I’m not sure there are any bands I’m closeted about. How about ‘out of the closet’ bands like Bronski Beat, Erasure, Pansy Division, Coil? Sid, do you remember catching me listening to Communards and informing me in no subtle terms what one generally does while enjoying Jimmy Somerville’s singing?
I suppose none of my friends share my love of Simply Red but I can’t hide it, that love shines.
And OMD rocks my socks. Teen Winkie once steered me toward “Junk Culture” but “Dazzle Ships” might be my favorite.
Robotnik | 12-May-05 at 4:00 am | Permalink
Hall & Oates
ABBA
Erasure
Electronic
New Order
Jodi | 12-May-05 at 1:08 pm | Permalink
Barry Manilow
Neil Diamond
Air Supply
Liza Minnelli
Ethel Merman (Some people….)
Am I a gay man? You decide.
Outside Prague | 12-May-05 at 1:16 pm | Permalink
Deep breath, no ones judging me, just admit it. Yello…I still listen to them at times.
Outside Prague | 12-May-05 at 1:47 pm | Permalink
My life has come full circle. I recently heard a country version of Black Flag’s “Nervous Breakdown”. It was recorded in ‘95 by a band called Whiskeytown. The same comp CD (lovingly removed from the bargain bin) has the Meat puppets doing a semi deranged country song called “Lost”. The most amusing part of the story, the CD is entitled “The Best of alt.country Exposed Roots”. I love it. Steve Earle appears also with “Guitar Town”. OK now I feel cleansed of all my musical sins. Thank you dear Sid for the outlet to let this out. I’m OK you’re OK.
Stacy | 13-May-05 at 12:16 am | Permalink
Yay Sid! I, too, have a secret love of Don Henley. Reading that made me get up and rush to my CD shelves to make sure good ol’ “End of the Innocence” was still there and unharmed. It is, praise be. It might just be rocked out to tomorrow on the drive in to work.
My guilt list:
* Rick Astley (I keep trying to make myself trade in the CD, but I can’t)
* ABBA
* NSYNC/Justin Timberlake (To make it even worse, I have to disclose that I don’t even feel guilty about loving Justin. He makes my booty shake. So there.)
Sharon | 13-May-05 at 11:40 pm | Permalink
Now you can marry your love of Eminem and Martika — he samples the chorus of “Toy Soldiers” on a song on his latest album (I think it’s called “Soldier”).
I’m one of Courtney Love’s fiercest fans. I see nothing wrong with loving her, and loving her hard (she likes it that way). I refuse to even be ashamed that I love her. She has shown me her breasts and I have basked in the glow of them. Even my baby sister, who was badly traumatized by a post-Kurt-suicide Hole concert I took her to in 1994, has realized the error of her ways and come around. Rock stars are supposed to behave badly. If they didn’t, they’d be Creed. I have no need for Creed in my life.
Sadly, I’ve gotten rid of a lot of my guilty pleasures. Like Betty Boo. I played the shit out of her. I’m sorry I ever got rid of Betty Boo. She made me dance. She made me do the do. But I’ve kept some other guilty pleasures, like Enya and Sam Phillips. And I’ve found new guilty pleasures, like The Darkness. And dammit, I am going to go to iTunes and buy Kelly Clarkson’s “Since U Been Gone” — I don’t care what anyone thinks!! I’m tired of sneak-listening to it at Circuit City!
the mighty jimbo | 21-May-05 at 4:40 pm | Permalink
reo speedwagon.
i gotta roll with the changes, even if they never did.
yangshuo now. hong kong tomorrow. sydney the following day. i believe it’s time for me to fly.
mer | 25-May-05 at 4:51 pm | Permalink
yes, “outside prauge”, even this blog has come full circle! Whiskeytown is fabulous and fits as their frontman was not “tom’s” Bryan Adams ‘i’m finding it hard to believe we’re in heaven’ but Ryan Adams ‘when you’re young you get sad and you get high’. (I wonder how often they get mixed up?)
“Robonik”, I don’t believe I could ever fizzle the love I once had for New Order, I still have to break out Brotherhood now and again…oh the pain, even the extended dance mixes! What could be more painful was my love of the band Trio in the late eighties. Not only the dadada song, but all of them! Ugh. Feh. Sigh.
“Chriss” just reading your list sent shivers as the relentless presence of a fat,furry and manic-eyed Meatloaf in a puffy pirate shirt did the ‘drop the penny dance’(refer to silly goth steps 101) in my mind. Years of therapy….ruined! heeheehee!
And sidmann…is it the new Lou barlow with a cover of ’round and round’? Ratt still rules with the post-30 whitebreads, whether we accept it or not!
And here’s my worst…my favorite record at age seven was the Jim and Tammy Faye Baker children’s album, PTL Favorites with songs like “man on the rock” and “oops there comes a smile”. I kid you not. Seeing as how I’m spending time at my folk’s house, I may be able to find the lp. A girl puppet and a puppet dog, was it???? eeegads! Ahhh. Free at last…
Jackie | 05-Jun-05 at 9:12 am | Permalink
Bob Seger
J. Giles Band
the Gap Band
Zapp
Sonny & Cher
(Raspy) Ruby | 18-Jun-05 at 12:51 pm | Permalink
I’ve been enjoying a resurgence of once-inexplicably popular and now virtually-spectred, large-haired duet Hall and Oates. Mock if you will, but “You Did it in a Minute” is a perfectly crafted and pleasantly melodic pop song. Rick Springfield’s “Love is Alright Tonite” (love the novelty spelling), recently resurrected for the film “Wet Hot American Summer” is rife with cliches and totally fabulous and rock-outable. Ditto for Jefferson Starship’s “Jane.” Remember Zebra, and their one and only honest-to-God hit, “Who’s Behind the Door”? Oh yeah. That’s one to hold the lighter to. I’d go on, but the crickets would be chirping long before I finished and I’d rather be an iPod geek in person. BTW, Happy Birthday, Sidney, a bit belated, but our birthdays are rather close and I just remembered. We’re so f-ing old! xoxo
shandana | 28-Jun-05 at 1:33 am | Permalink
well sid, you and i both know who i am going to say since you have karaoked with me on one of their mid-80s jams…
DURAN DURAN
but i feel no shame in saying that i love them. never have and never will. their albums have always been on proud display in my apartment. i wear their concert tees to the gym. people laugh when i say i love them. they guffaw when i say i saw them live and they fucking rocked the mother fucking house. “are they still around?” they ask. yeah, mother fuckers, they are and they rock and they STILL look good and create good music.
i will always be a new romantic looking for the tv sound…
Jimbodacious | 06-Jul-05 at 7:39 am | Permalink
Not being Catholic, I thought this might be a relatively painless way to try confession. Although I can’t say for sure that I won’t be going to hell anyway for admitting I like these bands….
Ted Nugent — I have to wait until the wife is at work to make the windows shake. But I happily began losing my hearing at concerts (Summer Jam!) throughout my teenage years and his riffy power chord tunes still make me reach for my trusty air guitar.
Michael Hedges — I’m sorry the guy couldn’t keep it on the road; we lost a good one there. But after actually watching him play (between bouts of deadline editing in a newspaper office we shared with a great Art Deco theater) and giving his music a fair hearing, I really like the melodies and technical virtuosity. That and I have a great download of him playing All Along the Watchtower. Brilliant.
Luther Wright and the Wrongs — Any Canadian country band who can do a complete cover of Pink Floyd’s The Wall in country music format kicks ass. Period. Buy the CD, you’ll fall in love with it.
George Winston — The king of elevator music (at least I hear him on the “hold” music here at work a lot) has some music that I like listening to when the time is right. Maybe it’s because I was turned on to him when I was breaking up with a long-time girlfriend, but his music stuck and she’s long gone.
Triumph — As guitar solos go, Rock-n-Roll Machine is as blisteringly fast and furious as it gets. Although I can live without the sappy balads, the other stuff I still like.
The Gun Club — “She’s Like Heroin to Me” remains an 80s fave. I play that and I’m instantly back to my early college days, stoned and briefly ignoring the papers that are due Monday.
Burt Bacharach — I mean, what can you say about a guy who’s written hits (and Academy Award nominated songs) for everyone from Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass to Tom Jones. And now more than ever, What the World Needs Now is Love.
Tom Lehrer — The only time I ever used the “78″ speed setting on my Lloyds groove grinder was to play my parents’ Tom Lehrer albums. Personal faves included “Be Prepared” and “New Math.” And they’re still funny as shit today.
LEO SPOON | 06-Dec-05 at 7:25 am | Permalink
Tammey f. baker she was marryed to jimmy baker from p.t.l. club. did tammy die